Expense Report Compliance: Tax Risks and Controls
Expense Report Compliance: The Tax Risk Groups Underrate
When finance and control teams rank expense report risks, tax and regulatory compliance rarely comes first. Fraud and failing approvals feel more urgent, errors more visible. Tax exposure, by contrast, stays silent. It does not disrupt the month-end close or trigger alerts in the expense tool. It surfaces later, sometimes years later, when a tax authority reviews a sample of claims and finds that the documentation does not hold.
This article is part of a series that grew out of discussions with members of our User Club: finance, internal control and audit leaders from international groups operating across many countries and entities. Tax and regulatory risks were generally rated as a low priority. That assessment deserves a second look.
Why tax risk on expense reports is rarely a priority
The reason is largely a matter of timing. An expense claim is submitted, approved and reimbursed within weeks. Its tax consequences only materialise when the period is audited. By then, the employee may have left, the receipt may be unreadable, and the original approver may no longer remember the context.
For international groups, complexity compounds the problem. A group present in thirty countries faces thirty sets of rules on indirect tax recovery, on the tax and social treatment of reimbursed expenses, and on how long and in what form supporting documents must be retained. A policy written once at group level cannot capture all of them.
The exposure runs in both directions. Tax left unclaimed on eligible expenses is a lost saving; tax recovered on documents that do not meet local requirements is a liability that an audit can turn into reassessments and penalties. Under-recovery is a cost; over-recovery is a risk.
How VAT, payroll and retention rules create exposure
Four risks were identified in this family, each with its own mechanism.
Unjustified recovery of indirect taxes. Recovering VAT or equivalent taxes usually requires an invoice that meets local requirements: supplier tax identification, itemised amounts, sometimes the company’s name rather than the employee’s. A simple till receipt rarely qualifies. When recovery is applied by default to every eligible category, a share of it rests on documents that would not survive an audit. The rise of AI-generated receipts adds a new layer: fabricated documents may lack valid transaction or tax identification numbers, precisely the details a tax review checks.
Requalification as a benefit in kind. Depending on local rules, reimbursements that are not clearly business-related, or that exceed allowed allowances, can be treated as taxable remuneration. Personal portions of business trips, generous per diems, mileage allowances without supporting records or recurring meals with no identified business purpose are typical triggers. The consequence is a reassessment of payroll taxes and social contributions, often over several years.
An unreliable audit trail. When the link between the receipt, the approval and the accounting entry is broken, the company can no longer demonstrate why an expense was reimbursed and how it was recorded.
Failure to retain supporting documents. Retention periods and accepted formats vary from one country to another. Scanned receipts may or may not be sufficient; archives may be incomplete after a change of tool or a reorganisation.
A related exposure concerns gifts and hospitality. Expense reports are a common channel for invitations offered to clients, partners or officials. If these expenses cannot be easily identified in the accounts and traced back to their beneficiaries, they become a blind spot for anti-corruption controls.
Which controls secure VAT recovery and audit trail?
For each risk, a key control applies:
- Indirect tax recovery: periodic tax review combined with an audit on a targeted sample of claims.
- Benefits in kind: periodic review of sensitive expense categories and training for approvers on what may be requalified.
- Audit trail: secure electronic archiving and full traceability from receipt to ledger.
- Document retention: a formal archiving policy aligned with local requirements and a compliant storage solution.
These controls have one thing in common: they are performed after the fact, on a sample or a selection of claims. Their value therefore depends heavily on how that sample is chosen.
Why some groups choose not to recover VAT on expenses
Two practices stand out among the groups involved.
Targeted tax reviews after the fact. Rather than relying on the tax audit to reveal weaknesses, some groups carry out their own periodic reviews, annually or quarterly, on a targeted sample. The focus is on the compliance of supporting documents, incorrectly recovered VAT and expenses that were non-compliant but approved nonetheless. The sample is built on risk rather than chance: countries with strict invoicing rules, high-value categories, employees or entities with unusual patterns.
A deliberate choice of non-recovery. Some groups have made a counter-intuitive decision: not to recover VAT on most expense reports, and to recover it only on a few tightly framed cases, such as travel booked through the corporate agency with compliant invoices. The reasoning is that, for a large volume of small claims, the cost of documenting compliance and the risk of reassessment outweigh the tax recovered.
This is a legitimate trade-off, provided it is a documented decision rather than a default. It requires knowing what is forgone, reviewing the choice periodically and making sure that the categories where recovery is maintained are genuinely under control.
An illustrative case shows why. During an internal review, a group finds that one subsidiary has been recovering VAT systematically on restaurant receipts that do not meet local invoicing requirements. Each amount is small, but the practice has run for several years. The group faces a choice: correct and disclose, or wait for an audit that would add penalties to the reassessment. In both cases, the cost far exceeds the VAT that was recovered.
How to measure tax compliance on expense claims
Measuring tax compliance means checking, over time, that recovered taxes and reimbursed amounts would stand up to scrutiny. Useful indicators include:
- the share of recovered VAT supported by a compliant invoice, measured on a sample;
- the anomaly rate in periodic tax reviews, by country and by expense category;
- the share of claims without a document reference or with an unreadable receipt;
- the archive completeness rate: the proportion of sampled claims for which all supporting documents can be retrieved;
- the volume and trend of sensitive categories such as gifts, hospitality, per diems and mileage allowances.
These indicators turn a silent risk into a visible one. They also make it possible to reassess the trade-offs, such as non-recovery choices, on factual grounds.
A deferred risk is still a risk
Tax and regulatory risks on expense reports are underrated because their consequences are deferred. But a reassessment covering several years, with penalties, can cost more than many of the fraud cases that receive far more attention. The groups that manage this risk best treat it as part of their control framework rather than a matter for the tax department alone: they test documentation regularly, make explicit choices about recovery and measure whether their archives would hold up.
The next article in this series turns to one of the risk families the groups involved considered most critical: the failure of managerial control.
About the author:
François Vallana, CEO
François Vallana joined Sixthfin in 2026 as Chief Executive Officer, bringing extensive experience in scaling high-growth software, data and B2B platform businesses. He notably contributed to the rise of Enablon, acquired by Wolters Kluwer, before leading Vecteur Plus. His background spans technology, domain expertise and general management. François is driven by one ambition: turning Sixthfin’s technological edge into an essential market standard for finance, control and audit teams.
Published on 18.11.2026